CHRIS NEUMER: Back up. So you were talking about Down to You.
SHAWN HATOSY: Down to You, the director had an idea that my character was going to start off in a certain way and then I was gonna put on weight. Then there was gonna be this whole beat in between, where you see why he got heavy. Theres a whole scene, a whole story, and a whole plot line why he became that and they ended up cutting that little part out, so then hes just looking normal in the beginning and by the end I have a fat suit on and it was never explained. That kind of stuff can really screw up a performance and, when they edit things that it causes all kinds of disconnects. They had to make the movie. Obviously, things were going to get lost, but it does affect your performance when they cut out that scene that might lead to another scene that connected to the next scene
CHRIS NEUMER: I can I understand how that
SHAWN HATOSY: You have to be able to trust the director. I just did this thing, I was talking about ER last night, it was on ER and my character had multiple personalities and so they had asked me to come in. It was a tough character to read and I did. I ended up getting it and the director was wonderful to work with. I loved it. To play a character that complex; the transition from one character to the next character. He spent a lot of time with me and it was just awesome, I really enjoyed it and Im pretty happy with the final result. Most of the time Im this really obnoxious, jerk, asshole.
CHRIS NEUMER: Asshole, I was gonna say.
SHAWN HATOSY: (laughs) In the part.
CHRIS NEUMER: Oh. Yeah. The part
SHAWN HATOSY: (laughs) And then my character switches to this other guy, and its an hour long show. Anyway Im going off topic. I was gonna say something related to it, but I dont want it to be perceived that I didnt enjoy [it]. I loved absolutely everything about it. But if he had cut something, you know what I mean
CHRIS NEUMER: It could have really gone the other way?
SHAWN HATOSY: It could have really screwed the whole thing. Because Im three different personalities so if one of the things got taken out I wouldve just looked like a terrible actor.
CHRIS NEUMER: Trust almost seems like synergy in a way. Anytime people say, "Oh we have this great synergy," I always go, "Stop right there and define that word to me." No one has been able to define it because I think its almost a place saver. It allows you to try out figure out what Im trying to say and its sort of like me saying a word like "right now". Its a nice trick to get the other person to figure out what you mean without actually saying way you mean. But with the way youre describing it, Im actually getting the sense of it right now that, to you, trust in the director mean that hes not going to make you look like a gigantic ass. That you can have faith that youre gonna put in your best work and youre not gonna get burned in the end of it.
SHAWN HATOSY: Yes. Trust its the most important thing between an actor and a director. Ive only done one movie where it was just an awkward and I never even talked to the director before I agreed to do it.
CHRIS NEUMER: This was early on?
SHAWN HATOSY: It happened once.
CHRIS NEUMER: Like early on in your career Im assuming?
SHAWN HATOSY: Yeah, maybe within the last three to five years. Its the only time I never met the director before I agreed to do a part I just did it. I accepted it and I just didnt have any faith in the guy, it was awful.
CHRIS NEUMER: Did it affect your performance?
SHAWN HATOSY: Absolutely. It was the worst thing Ive ever done. (laughs) Its so important. Ill never do that again. Ill always meet them, Ill always talk to them
CHRIS NEUMER: So its probably good that you had that experience, because now you can this is the way I approach God knows how many different things in my life, which is, well Im glad that I did X, Y and Z because now I know not to do that again.
SHAWN HATOSY: Absolutely.
CHRIS NEUMER: It only works for so many things, but generally speaking
SHAWN HATOSY: Basically, you can repair anything. Its a perfect example of one of those things that you learn, its wisdom and you can always unless youre Mel Gibson, (laughs) fix any kind of damage thats done to your [career] I guess Im talking about a bad performance.
CHRIS NEUMER: Good save there. You bring this up and I equate this to. Im single. There are things now, because Im thirty, that come up in dating where its a red flag. Maybe not just a small red flag, its an enormous red flag. Like uh, Im trying to think about something like uh, I dont know Okay, if shes got her entire arm covered with tattoos. I hope your girlfriend doesnt have a tattoo on her arm.
SHAWN HATOSY: No.
CHRIS NEUMER: You know. Like from wrist to here. Shes got a huge tattoo. If I was 20, Id be like "oh yes". Now Im 30 and Im like oh, red flag. Im curious is there any sense of that with your acting, back when I was 20 or whatever, I saw this but now Im starting to see certain red flags, this one goes up, no Im not doing it.
SHAWN HATOSY: There are red flags.
CHRIS NEUMER: Not even specific for projects. Feel free to get as specific as you want, but Im saying just in general. Co-starring opposite Matthew Lillard
SHAWN HATOSY: A big red flag sometimes when you make a movie like this where theres no budget there are all these little red flags and Im used to doing things a certain way and with that comes theres a lot of experience here and its hard to do a movie that small.
CHRIS NEUMER: Less takes, less time.
SHAWN HATOSY: Less takes. Overall the understanding of the film process across the board, because were here in a small town.
CHRIS NEUMER: Not only that but people you hire are
SHAWN HATOSY: Theyre not experienced, which is okay, because its all a learning experience. But that can cause trouble.
CHRIS NEUMER: Not on this one?
SHAWN HATOSY: Not on this one.
CHRIS NEUMER: But other ones?
SHAWN HATOSY: There have been projects where you dont have as many takes. A movie like this with a small budget and not enough money to buy the best clothes, or get perfect props, or the right cars, or the right locations; it forces everybody on the creative level, to be creative. I mean, super creative. Like ubercreative. You have to come up with ways of doing things that you might not have thought could be done, but on the fly...
CHRIS NEUMER: And it seems you have to have an actor thats gotta be appealing?
SHAWN HATOSY: That is appealing, yeah. So I guess a red flag would be budget.
CHRIS NEUMER: But that wouldnt because you not to do it. That would because you to look at it more carefully.
Shown Hatosy: Look at it differently.
CHRIS NEUMER: Are there any things, like working with a first time director, which of course youve done, but is it something like that where youd like to see more experience or not working with a Russian DP who shot a ton of Scorpions videos or something.
SHAWN HATOSY: Ive never met a director, a first time director, and been like, "Nah, I dont think I can work with him because hes a first time director". Its the material thats the most important thing. Thats what draws everybody to it. And if theres a heart or a heart beat, something in there, thats where it all starts. I dont think that I ever met a first time director on any of my movies that I didnt believe in. Im trying to think. Maybe I have. I mean shit, I think Greg Marcks that was his first film.
CHRIS NEUMER: That was.
SHAWN HATOSY: Wayne Kramer, The Cooler, that was his first film. He might have done a short or something, but Im pretty sure that was his first film. Peter Sheridan, who directed Brostal Boy that was his first film; theres a bunch. All those guys are fantastic directors. Scott Caan who directed Dallas 362 that was his first and I just think hes brilliant.
CHRIS NEUMER: Really?
SHAWN HATOSY: Absolutely, I really do.
CHRIS NEUMER: Now lets get in to this, Scott Caan, I have not seen the movie, Im only curious because you take a public persona and you find out that hes a brilliant filmmaker.
SHAWN HATOSY: Doesnt seem like it goes together?
CHRIS NEUMER: Having not seen the film, no. But what Im saying is what makes him brilliant?
SHAWN HATOSY: I guess I can see where youre coming from. I didnt know him, I met him a couple of times.
CHRIS NEUMER: I still dont believe that Ben Affleck is an Oscar winning screenwriter; let me just put it like that. "Him, really?" No. That would never happen. And youre like, no no, it happened in 97.
SHAWN HATOSY: I think he is. I read his latest script and its good.
CHRIS NEUMER: Scott [Caan] or
SHAWN HATOSY: Ben [Affleck]. Scott Caan called me and asked me, he said I got a million bucks to make this movie and Im a fan of yours and Id like you to do it. I dont even know this guy. I know him from his reputation. I knew nothing about him and I just agreed to do it. Not thinking. Because actors do that often, "Yeah lets do this...
CHRIS NEUMER: Not the not thinking part, the lets do a movie
SHAWN HATOSY: (laughs) Yes, the lets do a movie. I said "Sure, sure, sure". And sure enough it happened. Scott comes from this theater in LA, called Playhouse West, he writes plays and they put them up there. Hes written between four and eight plays and Ive seen two of them. I saw two before I ended up working on the film and I was just blown away. I was really blown away. And Im not just saying that because were friends. I think hes an extreme talent. We made Dallas 362 and I was very happy. Its a cool movie and I would do anything that he asked me to do. Not only is he a good writer and director; hes a really good actor. I dont think that hes had the opportunity to really show what hes capable of doing because kind of what you were saying hes got a reputation or whatever. He looks a certain way but I think if given the chance he would hes actually gone on to make his next film with Giovanni, that he wrote, Giovanni Ribisi, Don Cheadle and Mira Sorvino. hear its very good.
CHRIS NEUMER: Now you got me curious, Im gonna have to go take a look at that. I always like when things dont quite match up. Like the first time Hilary Swank did Boys Dont Cry, its like that kind of thing. Now, youve gotten two based on true stories, right?
SHAWN HATOSY: Yeah.
CHRIS NEUMER: Factory Girl and Alpha Dog are both based on true stories. Now, is there an appeal to the based on a true story because its true?
SHAWN HATOSY: No, first of all, Ill start with Factory Girl, I didnt know to what extent it was before I read the script. And honestly, I think Andy Warhol has been done, its been done in films, weve seen it, its, "Ugh okay "
CHRIS NEUMER: This is true.
SHAWN HATOSY: But the script had a heart to it, the characters were solid and its really her story I mean its all about her. People started falling into place like Guy Pearse, whom I have a ton of respect for. The appeal was the heart and the script, the actors. I didnt know the director.
CHRIS NEUMER: He did, uh, Ravenous, right? I was trying to figure out where I knew his name from.
SHAWN HATOSY: Youre asking me the tough questions. I dont know.
CHRIS NEUMER: Is it possible that it had a heart because it is able to be drawn from a real story that really took place and so that maybe it had some elements to it that were in fact real, that gave it heart?
SHAWN HATOSY: I guess so.
CHRIS NEUMER: I know its all interconnected but my thing is this and this is why Im asking
SHAWN HATOSY: I know what youre saying.
CHRIS NEUMER: So far were together on these two.
SHAWN HATOSY: And Im sure what they did was amazing and Ive heard that they were amazing.
CHRIS NEUMER: I also gotten other people angry by saying that they were mimicking as opposed to acting.
SHAWN HATOSY: Im not gonna say that thats the way I feel, but Ive played real people. I had to play John McCain in this A&E Movie [Faith of My Fathers]. At first I was like, [whispers] "Im not even gonna read it," because I thought it was crap.
CHRIS NEUMER: I like how you have to whisper that.
SHAWN HATOSY: (laughs) And then I read it, because it was a good offer. And it wasnt about politics at all, it was about John McCain, and what he went through. It was heart breaking and I couldnt believe it; so I did it. I remember doing my research, reading the book and looking at him and thinking I could try (imitates McCains voice) to do a John McCain, but I just did it, I just did it.
CHRIS NEUMER: You sort of turned off the egos this .
SHAWN HATOSY: The ego. People liked my performance, including John McCain.
CHRIS NEUMER: They did? They liked it?
SHAWN HATOSY: I could never play Johnny Cash the way that Joaquin [Phoenix] played Johnny Cash. Hes a good actor Im with you, on the same page as you, I dont really need to see that
CHRIS NEUMER: Its interesting because everything is so interconnected. Its sort of like its a click, if you didnt know that Johnny Cash was a real person. If you took Walk The Line for example and instead of calling him Johnny Cash you called him something else, a made up name like Sam Francis, you know. I wonder whether that would have the same amount of soul.
SHAWN HATOSY: Probably not.
CHRIS NEUMER: One of the reasons, and this is what gets me into trouble at parties when I start yelling about the acting, if Im a housewife in Iowa I have something that I can judge Jamie Foxxs performance in Ray against. I know who real life Ray Charles is, I know who John McCain is, and therefore I look at you, are you like that? Whereas, you take a look at something like, you in 11:14 or you take a look at you in Outside Providence, I have nothing to base this on other than, do I buy it? With a real life character, it better be like that. And in every other movie its "well can I buy it or not?" You already buy it with the biopics.
SHAWN HATOSY: I like what youre saying. In a way, its a way for them to make an art house film but have a built an audience, say for instance youre going to make Dukes of Hazzard. You know people like Johnny Cash, so lets do it and lets see if we can get it close. I love all those actors.
CHRIS NEUMER: And theyre good, and they probably do really good jobs in the things they do, Im just sort of pushing back against the intense critical praise that they get. Lets look at this in a little bigger of a picture. Thats the thing that bothers me, look at Billy Bob Thornton in Bad Santa, I dont know if youve seen it but the year that came out, I thought, that is a fantastic performance of just a horrible man who some how is likeable, and its like nobody is talking about that, everybody is talking about Charlize [Theron] and its I wonder if I wrote it down, yes here it is, its "acting on steroids". Thats what it is, because you take a look at something like Walk the Line or whatever and youve probably taken the five highest moments of Johnny Cashs life, the five lowest moments of Johnny Cashs life and youve sort of put them together and it gives you the opportunity to display a huge broad range. Most stories you dont get that, like that you do.
SHAWN HATOSY: Yeah.
CHRIS NEUMER: I shouldnt be so good, if I werent so into this
SHAWN HATOSY: Well its exciting to talk about this though; I was genuinely interested in seeing what Jim Carrey would do as Andy Kaufman, because I love Andy Kaufman. Did the movie really show me anything ? No, not really, he did a good job, I loved Milos Forman, hes one of my favorite directors, I just kind of walked away feeling like "yeah, it was all right" but whats the point. What did we discover? What really gets me off is character driven movies like Diner. Thats one of my favorite movies, I love those guys talking, I can see them their in my life, I know exactly who they are, they have some sort of personal meaning, I love movies where its like being there.
CHRIS NEUMER: Peter Sellers.
SHAWN HATOSY: Yeah, Being There. Just a great movie. All character, I really get off on that.
CHRIS NEUMER: This is even going to sound flippant now, compared to the ones that youve just mentioned but even something like Super Troopers, which I dont know if youve seen? But one of my favorite comedies, or when you get something like Caddy Shack , even though its funny again, the characters work and its not just the formula.
SHAWN HATOSY: Good acting too.
CHRIS NEUMER: Good actors in that movie. Lets be honest, Chevy Chase is many things, but, hes probably sitting in a café in West Hollywood right now and his ears just perked up and "I feel a ringing, what happened", somewhere in the Eastern Time Zone someone called me a good actor.
SHAWN HATOSY: You watch the TV show Taxi, I love that show, its character, all those actors, Christopher Lloyd, Danny DeVito, Judd Hirsch, Andy Kaufman, Andy Kaufman is great. Theyre all character, straight actors. That show worked on so many levels because of the writing. Because they werent playing these broad jokes, they were just being these sometimes repulsive, yet loveable characters.
CHRIS NEUMER: Thats funny. I was out in LA and say maybe 4 minutes of that show, King of Queens. I hope your not affiliated with it. It turned out that the guy [Kevin James] had bought stock in something and his wife [Leah Remini] didnt know about it, so it went up. And then she wanted to sell, and he said no, no we can make more money and then it went down and she said lets sell now and he said no, no, its going to go back up and it went further down and he then panicked and he sold it. Then, the stock went up. So the wife was really really happy and so he had to tell her that he had sold it and she got really depressed, and the stock kept going up so he bought it again and then it really went down. I was watching this and it was like, this is not funny, this is brutal, this wouldnt have even worked in Diffrent Strokes. It just seems like what were talking about is the idea of forcing something versus just sort of letting it happen. (points at the bartender) Like her, shes probably at least a little bit amused by sitting here and listening to the weird things were talking about.
BARTENDER: (laughs) Slightly, I havent heard a lot of it.
SHAWN HATOSY: What were saying is that there are only so many combinations of what you can do on a half hour comedy, with the same characters then regurgitating the same thing over and over
CHRIS NEUMER: Anything. Even like the sports movie, its been done but the point is if you do it right
SHAWN HATOSY: Then youve done something.
CHRIS NEUMER: Million Dollar Baby, which I really didnt like but the first movie, in that movie, the one where shes boxing, everybodys been there, youve probably been in four of these movies where like an underdog whos really kicking ass. But I was watching it and it was done really well, because the characters were there and its not bad just because its formula, its bad because thats all you throw into it. How do you deal with it? Well, you were in a Freddy Prince movie, so we can start there. You have something thats pretty formulaic; do you have any way that you try to un-formula it?
SHAWN HATOSY: Thats the whole goal, you need it. Especially with television because its written in such a way the goal is to kind of be like a painter, I hate to sound like a dork, but to make it blend and it seem like its real, even though what weve got is the stock going up or the stock going down. You want to make it seem as real as possible, and thats what I do.
CHRIS NEUMER: Often people tell me they are draw to a certain quality that a character has or the subtext, Im always interested to know how you go from sort of just feeling that you want to do something to translating it into an action that you do on set
SHAWN HATOSY: No, for me its not. Its like having this conversation and having a drink.
CHRIS NEUMER: But you dont know where the conversation is going, thats the difference. For us, youve got absolutely no clue whats around that next corner, you have no idea what Im going to bring out next. What Im saying is, whereas in a script, maybe Im going to start talking about whether or not hot women can be into the concept vampires. Who knows. You have to display that same reaction knowing thats its coming, so do you have any sense of certain things that you do, is it like "I do this gesture, or I do that" or is it just, youre not thinking about using yourself as a sort of marionette.
SHAWN HATOSY: (laughs) Its really not. Every character has an objective (laughs) so if youre in whatever that head space is then, its really about that focus.
CHRIS NEUMER: When you say focus, focus on what?
SHAWN HATOSY: I wish I could give you an example. But I cant its impossible to articulate. [Im really going to have the readers nailed to the wall.]
CHRIS NEUMER: Well, its not a Q&A so were all right.
SHAWN HATOSY: If you know your material and youre working with good people and its always different every time, theres something that happens and its this spontaneity that makes it good, seemingly fresh. [When actors are good together], its always different...
CHRIS NEUMER: I dont think it was Hitchcock, it might have been David Lean when he needed actors to cry, or actresses to cry, he would actually poke them with needles. They would start yelping and hed be "Okay, now Ive got it". There are other people, I think it was Julia Roberts who said that she thought of this leather coat she had lost when she was 17 or something and that got her crying. Thats the complete opposite from one another. One persons just thinking of a leather coat and other persons physically being injured.
SHAWN HATOSY: Have you ever read this book, Making Movies by Sidney Lumet its really a good one. If youre interested in the process of making a movie, he takes it from the very beginning all the way through the whole process; lighting, to editing, to working with actors, its a great read, if youre into filmmaking. Ive lost interest, somewhere in the past 5 years, in watching films. I dont know why. I dont know what happened, something got lost.
CHRIS NEUMER: Believe it or not, Im getting to that point.
SHAWN HATOSY: Ive watched enough. Maybe Ive become jaded because Im so involved, I dont know what it is. I was really excited to see Borat. (laughs) Because it was just this whole new thing, something that Id never seen before and it made me laugh and made me think.
CHRIS NEUMER: I dont know how that ties into anything necessarily, but its an interesting point. Someone told me recently that I was the only film writer they had ever met who proactively tries not to watch movies.
SHAWN HATOSY: I dont know why Ive lost interest. It used to be that if it were a Martin Scorsese film, its fucking Martin Scorsese, Im going to go see it, I dont care. I didnt see The Departed, but I hear its really good, but I would be there first in line.
CHRIS NEUMER: Interesting. The interest that you had in seeing these films, where has that gone? Im assuming theres a space in you that needs to be entertained and it used to be entertained by the films. Is it you being entertained by video games or your son or something?
SHAWN HATOSY: Yeah, yeah I guess. Video games, guitar. I just dont know why [films] have to be so big? Why do they have to be $100 million dollars? Why do they have to be so expensive, why do they have to do that?
CHRIS NEUMER: Particularly on that one [question], if you see Star Wars you can sort of go, okay I get it, but with The Departed
SHAWN HATOSY: Yeah, because its a character piece. Did you see Factotum ? It was pretty good.
CHRIS NEUMER: Ive heard of it in passing.
SHAWN HATOSY: Charles Bukowski; with Matt Dillon. I went, I saw it, I liked it, and I enjoyed it. Artsy fartsy but its very good
CHRIS NEUMER: No, the last thing I saw was Catch of Fire, Tim Robins. I realized that its only terrorism if its against you. If I was thrusting forth my beliefs on to you, thats not terrorism itd be something else. Its funny to think about that. I have so many problems with calling them a terrorist who are attacking the troops because of the definition of a terrorist: Anybody who attacks armed military personnel is a guerilla warrior. Terrorists attack the public. Its a minor semantic point but it just bothers the hell out of me when they keep calling them terrorists attacking the troops, "thats not it". Thats the same type of thing with this definition, which is it seems in the movie, it was set in South Africa during the Apartheid, and its basically this black guy that becomes revolutionary and he wants to blow up an oil rig and its sort of, on one hand were cheering for him because hes the lead character and we see what everyone is doing is wrong, but on the other hand, lets just shift this around a little bit, what if somebody were trying to blow up the World Trade Center? Okay thats weird. Certainly V for Vendetta in that way which you probably havent seen.
SHAWN HATOSY: Havent seen. I did see star wars, though.
CHRIS NEUMER: Now this is interested here. Where did I write this one down? Star Wars from the perspective of a Storm Trooper. What got me thinking was, I wonder how a Storm Trooper, the British guys with the green berets on, I wonder how they would view these rebels? Id love to be on that conversation. This small group of people just wont join the rest of the universe, they just keep attacking us, they just keep making our lives terrible, and we have to go scouring the universe for these five people, who are just determined to bring us down. We gotta go where? They did what? They killed how many?
SHAWN HATOSY: (laughing) They blew up the
CHRIS NEUMER: Thats right, they blew up They flew into our new ship. The one weve been spending thirty years working on it. And they blew it up with these ships that are like a 1974 Dodge equivalent. God damn, we just spent all this time building this thing and you know, Id love to see Star Wars from that perspective.